Research all NYC schools

Research Now

My Interview Experience at Bard High School Early College Queens

January 23, 2021 Noa Costom

I had the experience of applying to both public and private high schools as an eighth-grader, and because of the vastness of my application process, I had unique exposure to interviews. Over the course of two months, I sat down with representatives from six different schools and was evaluated for my performance. What both intrigued and perplexed me was that I could utter the same phrase at Trinity and have it be received entirely differently than at Beacon. Different schools expected different attire and levels of formality, and some schools had unspoken interview rules, like that you must write a thank you letter to your interviewer to get accepted. 


By far the most important lesson I learned from paying attention to the nuanced undertones of my six interviews was this: when it comes down to it, interviews are about assessing fit, that is how well a potential student is likely to acclimate to the academic and social dynamics of a school. With this in mind, the key to a successful high school interview is tapping into what distinguishes the school at hand from all other institutions and how it matches you as an individual. Consequently, only when you leave an interview both feeling that you have represented yourself well and feeling genuinely interested in the school can you be sure that you aced it.


My current school, Bard High School Early College Queens (BHSECQ), has an interview component to its admissions process which reflects its values to a tee. When I walked into the school for my interview three years ago, I was immediately struck by the variety of clothing worn by my fellow applicants. While I wore a blazer and skirt, the other girl waiting to be interviewed had jeans and a plain long sleeve on, and the boy next to me wore a button-down. At the time, I found this unnerving, but what I’ve come to realize is that this fits with BHSECQ’s aesthetic well. There is neither a literal or figurative dress code. Students wear what makes them feel good, whether that be leggings, baggy jeans, or pajamas. The school is ideal for people with a carefree, non-judgemental outlook on style (which is not the case for all students, and that is okay). 


I waited a few minutes before being called into my interview. Unlike some other schools, BHSECQ conducts interviews one-on-one, so I was alone with a teacher. The questions asked were routine: What is your favorite subject? Do you do extracurriculars? What’s your favorite book? Have you faced any significant academic challenges, and if so, how did you overcome them? What was not routine was the way my interviewer engaged with me and my answers. She addressed me with no condescension. I could have told her my favorite book was Goodnight Moon and she would only want to know why. We had a long conversation about Judaism and community, and then transitioned to soccer. Like Bard, the interview was stimulating and warm, and it centered around unpacking me as a person. I was afforded the opportunity to ask questions, which was not the case for many of the schools I interviewed for. I walked out exhilarated by the depth of the discussion and I knew that I wanted to spend more time at a place like Bard. 


Noa Costom is a junior at Bard High School Early College Queens. She enjoys reading, running, and backpacking. 

Join to NYCMentors.org

Join today and have a high school mentor guide your child through their middle school years

Join Now

Other articles

  • img

    NYC High School Preparation Guide for Sixth Grade 2021

    • March 04, 2021
    • NYC Mentors.org Staff

    The transition from fifth grade to sixth grade is significant. For most students, this is the first time that they will be adjusting to a new school environment with new expectations regarding their work and learning. Though the start of middle school can be daunting for most families, this guide will show that there is nothing to be afraid of! By following these steps, families can make the most of the start to their child’s middle school career and begin preparing for the high school admissions process.

    Read More

  • img

    Public Schools With Sports Programs Around NYC

    • February 26, 2021
    • Maybelle Keyser-Butson

    Finding public high schools for athletes in New York City -- a city filled with academic high schools, performing arts high schools, and technical high schools, but very few athletic high schools -- is not as easy as it sounds. Finding an athletic public high school that also offers the academics that match your athletic child’s abilities can be even more difficult. Parents can spend hours clicking on slow-to-load high school ranking sites, only to find that the schools are not easily accessible from their home, or not academically rigorous enough, or not a public high school.

    Read More

  • img

    Virtual Auditions - New Guidelines for Applying to NYC Arts High Schools in 2021

    • February 10, 2021
    • Oliwia Caes

    Global pandemic or not, the time to apply to high schools has come. There is no need, however, to become intimidated by an online audition process. Truth be told, the fact that it is virtual allows you to present your best work from the comfort of your own home and hopefully gives you all the more reason to apply.

    Read More

  • img

    How to Write High School Admissions Essays

    • February 08, 2021
    • Jacob Brucker

    A key part of the high school admissions process is writing essays. For me, these essays were the chief part of the application and the thing I placed the most emphasis on. These essays would vary in length, question type, and style, but through my time applying to high school, I found there were three universal steps that helped my writing. I continue to use these three criteria in my normal essays and know they can help you write your high school essays for applications. Here are the three criteria I use for my essays.

    Read More