Research all NYC schools

Research Now

Three Questions Families Want the DOE to Answer

October 09, 2020 Halina de Jong-Lambert, Jacob Brucker

With a chaotic start to the school year, most families have been focusing on understanding how their children will be educated through online, hybrid, or socially-distanced in-person learning. Despite experiencing all of the changes to classroom learning, there are still a lot of changes that families are asking about for this upcoming school year from the Department of Education (DOE). 

1. How will the DOE administer the SHSAT this year?

At the time of writing, the Department of Education has not updated the registration for the Specialized High School Admissions Test since last year. On the public school directory MySchools, one can find that the registration still reads October 10, 2019. Doing a little more searching one can find the registration date on the “2021 NYC High School and Specialized High Schools Admissions Guide,” which as of right now is October 21, 2020. Other DOE resource pages are still unclear about what the examination for New York City’s specialized public high schools will look like this year. On the page dedicated to these schools, it states that “registration will begin in early September and that students should contact their school counselors to register.” With the current problems families are dealing with starting school this year, this creates more questions than it answers.

Only slightly more information about the administration of the test can be found on the admissions guide. It says the SHSAT is scheduled for November 7 and 8 (with November 15 and 21 for makeups) for English Language learners and students with learning differences who have Individualized Education Programs or approved 504 plans. Yet, there is a lack of information regarding how the tests will be held. The question is touched on implicitly in the admissions guide, which says that the information will be on the test ticket. The best thing for a family to do is reach out to their guidance counselor while more information is to come. 


Will there be physical socially-distanced testing?

2.  How will auditions work for performing arts high schools?

In addition to the eight test-based specialized public schools, there is one exception: Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School of Music Art and Performing Arts. Unlike the others, the way students are admitted into LaGuardia is by audition. Unfortunately, for students interested in performing arts it is unclear how LaGuardia and other performing arts high schools will be conducting admissions. At the time of writing, LaGuardia has stated on their website that “Students may prepare for the audition before the final process is announced. The adjusted process will include parts of our regular process.” Unfortunately, most performing arts high schools have not updated their websites to say what the 2020-2021 high school audition process will look like, but it is clear the process will be adapted to COVID-19 restrictions.

At the moment the possibilities seem to be Zoom auditions (which can potentially open equity problems regarding internet-access) or submission of self-tapes, which are recordings of one’s performance. LaGuardia plans to have all auditions be self-taped, so watching online audition tapes submitted for virtual competitions this year could be valuable to learn what a self-taped audition looks like if you have not done one before. Though the admissions process this year is particularly unusual for performing arts students, families can still prepare themselves for however the process will look by continuing to practice their art forms. 

3. What selection criteria are screened schools using this year?

Unlike specialized public high schools, screened public schools are those which use a set of criteria to rank their applicants such as Townsend Harris High School. These criteria usually consist of seventh-grade grades, absences, and test scores. For this year though, it looks like none of these will be used in ranking students.

  • Grades: Typically, grades are weighted based on the traditional scale of 0-100 for the selection criteria to screened schools, but since the introduction of online learning, the Department of Education Chancellor Richard Carranza has canceled this scale. In its place, qualitative descriptions have been used to judge students' performance such as “Meets Standards” (MT), “Needs Improvement” (N), or “Course in Progress” (NX). This makes it almost impossible to rank applicants based on grades.
  • Attendance: In general, attendance is an important factor for admission into screened schools, which is why some students try their best to achieve perfect attendance. Due to COVID-19, however, officials stated that “Attendance during all of the 2019-20 school year will not be considered in admissions decisions for students who will begin middle or high school in September 2021.” Therefore, absences will be another factor excluded in the selection criteria of these schools.
  • Test Scores: Usually, public school students in the seventh-grade have to take NY State Assessments in ELA and Math, but the state decided to cancel these exams this past school year. Test scores are important for both public and private school admissions and are a way that schools can compare students among other applicants. Since eighth-grade families do not have any test scores this year, it is unclear how the DOE will replace this criterion for screened schools.

During these tough times, there continues to be uncertainty and fear about the future, especially for families in middle school. These questions highlight the information that the DOE should consider answering in upcoming updates so that families can feel more at ease. We here at are trying our best to spread information about any changes, and we hope that more news will be coming out soon to make this year of unprecedented changes easier for families. 

Halina de Jong-Lambert is a sophomore at Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School of Music Art and Performing Arts in New York City. She is an acting major at the school, enjoys Stephen King Novels, and is a fan of Oscar Wilde.

Jacob Brucker is a senior at Xavier High School in NYC. He is an editor of the school newspaper Xavier Review, loves to spend time outdoors, and hopes to major in business in college next year. 

Join to

Join today and have a high school mentor guide your child through their middle school years

Join Now

Other articles

  • img

    How Volunteering and Extracurriculars Can Affect Applications and Where to Go?

    • April 11, 2023
    • Dean Domingo

    Volunteering and extracurriculars are activities that can benefit both the community and yourself. For middle school students, volunteering and doing extracurriculars provide opportunities to develop new skills and interests and demonstrate to high schools that you are well-rounded and hardworking. High Schools are always looking for capable students willing to do more than what is required. So if you’re not doing extracurriculars and/or volunteering, getting the headstart and being a part of a club or helping out your community is the best way to demonstrate to schools that you are a hardworking and all-around person.

    Read More

  • img

    Tips for Attending High School Information Sessions

    • March 28, 2023
    • Sereia Sarumida

    Public high school admissions decisions came out on March 9th, and families have until April 5th to accept an offer. Many high schools are now offering information sessions, open houses, and virtual events for accepted students. These events are the perfect opportunity to ask students and teachers detailed questions about the schools, so you can decide which one is the best fit for you. If you have trouble getting started thinking of questions to ask, asking these sample questions (divided by topic) can help you to consider a broad range of factors to decide on a school to attend!

    Read More

  • img

    How to Write an Outstanding Essay for your High School admission process

    • February 21, 2023
    • David Romero

    The highschool admission process is very stressful. With all of its different required parts, the essay section of the application can be really overlooked. The essays are a chance for the admission officer’s to get an insight into who the applicant really is. Numerous people can have very similar transcripts, but a creative and charismatic essay will make an application stand out.

    Read More

  • img

    How to Ask for a Recommendation Letter and How to Pick the Right Candidate for the Job

    • February 12, 2023
    • Dean Domingo

    Recommendation letters are a key aspect of high school applications and are a great way to demonstrate your character and abilities from another perspective. While not mandatory in some schools, it’s highly encouraged and should be seen as a requirement. But, who do you ask for a recommendation letter? Choosing who to ask is very important and should be someone that has seen your growth as a student. Most schools usually require at least one recommendation letter from a core teacher (Math, Science, Social Studies, etc) and one letter from either another teacher, mentor, coach, or counselor. So after making a list of potential candidates take some time to consider a very important question. “Who knows you the most?”. If you choose a candidate that barely knows you, their letter may sound disingenuous and phony. So when selecting a recommender, you should consider someone who has had a significant impact on your life and should be someone who knows you both academically and personally and can attest to your abilities, interests, achievements, and growth.

    Read More